The Sarasota area continues to be a beacon for luxury living, and 2024 was no exception. From contemporary masterpieces to timeless estates, these high-dollar sales highlight the appeal of Sarasota’s pristine waterfronts, architectural innovation, and world-class amenities. Here’s a detailed look at the top 10 most expensive home sales of the year:
No. 10: $12.8 Million – 1325 Westway Drive, Sarasota
This architectural gem in Lido Shores was designed by Mark Sultana of DSDG Architects and built by Voigt Brothers Construction. Owned by David and Linda Hargreaves, the property features 6,590 square feet of contemporary design, inspired by the Sarasota School of Architecture. Highlights include clerestory windows, extensive use of glass, a rooftop putting green, a deepwater dock, and a courtyard with a pool and fire bowls.
The new owners, Matthew and Desiree DeSoto, were drawn to the home’s modern aesthetic and private beach access. Matthew, CEO of Miter Brands, recently oversaw a $3.1 billion acquisition of PGT Innovations.
No. 9: $12,995,000 – 1561 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Unit 401, Longboat Key
Located in the newly completed St. Regis Residences, this luxury condo was purchased by Cayo Lancha LLC, linked to L. Neil Hunn, CEO of Roper Technologies. The residence reflects the pinnacle of modern condominium living, with unparalleled amenities, Gulf views, and exclusive services offered by the St. Regis.
No. 8: $13 Million – 1561 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Unit 204, Longboat Key
Another St. Regis unit, this property was bought by Jason and Rachel Ghormley, founders of Hydrologic, a Florida-based plumbing supply company. The unit offers luxurious interiors and breathtaking Gulf vistas, making it a prime piece of Longboat Key’s upscale real estate.
No. 7: $13.5 Million – 1591 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Unit 218, Longboat Key
A third St. Regis condo makes the list, purchased by Michael and Tracy Kukuselis. Michael, a software engineer and co-founder of Clarity Innovations, acquired this unit to enjoy its waterfront views, modern design, and exclusive amenities.
No. 6: $14.5 Million – 8218 Sanderling Road, Sarasota
This Gulf-to-lagoon property in the Sanderling Club spans four acres, offering private beach access and a guesthouse overlooking Heron Lagoon. The main home, built in 1986, features over 8,600 square feet of living space with stunning water views. Earl Weinman, CEO of Propper International Sales, acquired this rare estate to enjoy its unique blend of privacy and natural beauty.
No. 5: $14,995,000 – 4300 Higel Ave., Sarasota
This Siesta Key property sold in just four days, showcasing its exceptional allure. Designed by Clifford Scholz and built by Perrone Construction, the home features Georgian-inspired architecture with six bedrooms, marble finishes, and expansive waterfront views. Mitchell Schepps, a Florida-based business law expert, is the latest owner.
No. 4: $16,995,000 – 4136 Higel Ave., Sarasota
Developed by Seaward Development, this newly constructed home on Siesta Key offers 7,460 square feet of living space, a rooftop terrace, an infinity pool, and an eight-car garage. Its contemporary design and Gulf views make it a standout property in the luxury market.
No. 3: $19.75 Million – 6633 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key
“Ohana,” a unique property inspired by African and Polynesian architecture, boasts a private stretch of Gulf shoreline. With mahogany and teak finishes, geothermal systems, and multiple residential pods, this property combines sustainability with luxury. It was purchased by an LLC linked to the Wanek family, founders of Ashley Furniture Industries.
No. 2: $20 Million – 1233 Hillview Drive, Sarasota
Located in the prestigious Harbor Acres neighborhood, this 11,275-square-foot estate set a local record with its $20 million sale. Built in 2022, the home offers eight bedrooms, 12 bathrooms, and more than 140 feet of direct waterfront. The buyer, represented by a trust, acquired this modern marvel at a significant discount from its original $34 million listing price.
No. 1: $21,244,000 – 1561 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Units 201 and 202, Longboat Key
The most expensive sale of the year was a combined condo at the St. Regis Residences. Spanning 10,887 square feet, the property includes six bedrooms, a private plunge pool, and access to world-class amenities. The buyer, John M. Arnold, heir to PPC Lubricants, set a Sarasota County record with this purchase.
Final Thoughts
These remarkable sales underscore Sarasota’s appeal to affluent buyers seeking luxury, privacy, and architectural excellence. Whether it’s a contemporary condo at the St. Regis or a sprawling estate on Siesta Key, the area continues to deliver some of the finest properties in the world. As 2025 approaches, it will be exciting to see how Sarasota’s luxury market evolves.
Interested in finding your slice of Sarasota paradise? If you're considering buying or selling a luxury property in Sarasota, now is the perfect time to connect with a local expert. Contact us today to explore the best opportunities in Sarasota’s luxury real estate market. Let’s make your real estate dreams a reality in 2025.
